It’s Always Been Fanfiction; The Boundary of Legitimacy Between Fanfiction and Adaptation
Loading...
Authors
Robertson, Alexandra E.
Date
Type
thesis
Language
eng
Keyword
fanfiction , adaptation , copyright , legitimacy , storytelling
Alternative Title
Abstract
Adaption as a mode of storytelling is often praised within the mainstream, while fanfiction, which similarly builds off an existing text, is considered unworthy of the same praise. Instead, fanfiction is often accused of, being ‘unoriginal’, ‘simplistic’, and ‘poorly written’. This major research paper aims to identify how this separation between adaptation and fanfiction is reinforced through the notion of legitimacy. Legitimacy dictates what is considered worthy of attention in the mainstream and its purpose is to serve a hierarchy of art and taste.
This paper claims that legitimacy, in this case, is made up of four parts: legality, credibility, acceptability, and profitability. Legality examines the ways that copyright laws and fair use dealings have created a grey zone for the creation of transformative works like fanfiction. Credibility details how the author and canon attempt to hold power, and the ways that they are unable to retain that power. Acceptability examines the ways in which adaptation and authorship are male coded, while fanfiction is dismissed due to being a female coded practice. Profitability is the revenue that can be made off of each style of work in a capitalist society and the associated valuing of the work.
After the boundary is established of what creates a legitimate and illegitimate work in the mainstream, this paper examines how the boundary does not ultimately stand up to scrutiny by examining two works: BBC’s Sherlock and Cassandra Clare’s The Mortal Instruments. These works do not hold up to the boundary, as they are unable to be completely legitimate or illegitimate. Ultimately, this paper argues that the boundary, as must fail to allow the continued, unencumbered production of art.
Description
Citation
Publisher
License
Queen's University's Thesis/Dissertation Non-Exclusive License for Deposit to QSpace and Library and Archives Canada
ProQuest PhD and Master's Theses International Dissemination Agreement
Intellectual Property Guidelines at Queen's University
Copying and Preserving Your Thesis
This publication is made available by the authority of the copyright owner solely for the purpose of private study and research and may not be copied or reproduced except as permitted by the copyright laws without written authority from the copyright owner.
Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International
ProQuest PhD and Master's Theses International Dissemination Agreement
Intellectual Property Guidelines at Queen's University
Copying and Preserving Your Thesis
This publication is made available by the authority of the copyright owner solely for the purpose of private study and research and may not be copied or reproduced except as permitted by the copyright laws without written authority from the copyright owner.
Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International