Brace Yourself: Reducing Medial Knee Loading for Treatment of Osteoarthritis

Thumbnail Image
Brandon, Scott
Knee Contact , OpenSim , Osteoarthritis , Musculoskeletal Model , Static Optimization , Knee Brace
Compared with healthy controls, subjects with medial knee osteoarthritis walk using similar kinematics but greater activation of knee-spanning muscles, especially on the lateral side of the knee (furthest from centerline of the body). Although muscle forces generally compress the knee joint, it had been speculated that this specific activation pattern actually reduces compressive loads across the medial (closest to centerline) side of the knee where osteoarthritis is most common. It is not feasible to measure intra-articular contact forces in biological human knee joints. Therefore, a musculoskeletal simulation was developed to estimate the effect of elevated activation on knee contact forces. A generic musculoskeletal model was adapted to account for subject-specific frontal-plane alignment of the knee joint, and modified to isolate the medial and lateral components of the compressive knee contact load. The model’s predictions were validated using in vivo data obtained from a subject with an instrumented knee prosthesis. Subsequently, the model was used to demonstrate that elevated muscle activation, as found in osteoarthritis subjects, does not protect against harmful medial loads, but actually contribute to an increase in peak load shortly after heel-strike. Since osteoarthritis subjects did not appear to adopt a protective gait pattern, the second half of the dissertation was devoted to the evaluation of a clinical device that is known to reduce medial loads during gait: the knee unloader brace. To accomplish medial unloading, braces apply a frontal plane abduction moment to the knee which, if large enough, would pry open the medial contact surfaces. A novel method was developed to non-invasively compute the abduction moment applied by the brace to each subject’s leg using a mechanical stiffness calibration. The computed brace moment was incorporated into the musculoskeletal model in order to quantify relative contributions of muscle forces, inverse dynamic joint loads, and the applied brace load in reducing medial contact forces for treatment of medial knee osteoarthritis. The model revealed that kinematic, muscular, and inverse dynamic changes were dominated by the large applied brace moment. The medial unloading effect of knee braces could be enhanced by reducing external and muscle forces through gait modification.
External DOI